When Natalie was 16, she lived with her dad and Chacey for six months and never saw him become violent. According to Park Cities People, police connected Garza and Chacey Poynter through Facebook. SHANE MEEK: What what, tell me his name again, I'm sorry. Nicole Poynter |Victim's daughter: I remember the bagpipes. Chacey Poynter: Nothing really set it off. Amy says in the last days of his life, Robert was finally ready to walk away from Chacey. Everything she told them in breathless and halting sentences was captured by police body cameras, including an admission that she was having problems in her marriage. She confessed they were having an affair and she'd had sex. Since Chacey had told officials her then-boyfriend Michael Garza was the triggerman after shed essentially lured Robert to the rural road within hours of the incident, both were arrested. Jeff Kovach: That shotgun was still loaded. She told police she had no idea who fired the fatal shot. On September 15, 2016, just five days after his wife was charged in his death, Captain Robert Poynter was laid to rest. Chacey Poynter: Correct. Chacey Poynter: I knew I wanted to marry him. According to the State Department of Corrections records, he will be eligible for parole on September 10, 2046. and often my little sister would wake up and cry and cry because she couldn't find her mom. Even later that day, she intended to have sex with another partner. We slept in separate bedrooms. BRAD GOLDEN: She would be at my house every day, every day, around 4 to 5 o'clock. Where Are Robert Poynters Daughters Now. The NBC episode further reveals his cell phone also pinged from around this same area on that fateful night, which made his alibi of tending to a cow during the exact window a bit unbelievable. #48HOURS IN 48 SECONDS: The sole witness to a murder helps police make sense of a bewildering crime scene. We spoke to friends. Peter Van Sant: And could you tell if that blast was shot from forward of the vehicle or from behind? Chacey Poynter: I don't think I reacted to the sound It was Robert. We had guards guarding his urn, his ashes, the entire time. Chacey Poynter and Michael Garza were convicted of murdering Chacey's husband, Fire Captain Robert Poynter. SGT. Earl Starnes: We waited for a while An hour, two hours, three hours went by. "And, as soon as that that shot, he slumped over into the passenger seat," Poynter tells "48 Hours" correspondent Peter Van Sant in her first network TV interview. And I just I was calling his name. I think of Bob every day I come up here. He also had a $685,000 life insurance policy taken out, and Chacey Poynter was the beneficiary of that policy. DET. From the moment police arrived at the scene, they were skeptical of Chacey's story of what happened. Jason Salisbury | Firefighter: Honestly, it's one of those things you don't even believe it at first. Amy Poynter: From what I understand, she continued to go up to the station to kind of let him know that she was interested and did that quite often. CHACEY POYNTER: There was someone standing there. SGT. Chacey Poynter: You know, I don't walk out and announce he's beating on me. Sgt. A man and woman have been charged in the murder of the womans husband, a Texas fire captain, police said. Absolutely. Chacey Poynter and Michael Garza were arrested this weekend after her 47-year-old husband, Robert Poynter, was found shot dead in his truck Friday night in Royse City, Texas, according to a police press release. Amy Poynter: One of the hardest things is they give the Last call for Robert Poynter. He added that she was his first murder suspect. Photo courtesy Hunt County Detention Center. A selfie captured one intimate moment. However, the appeals court still upheld the conviction. Shane Meek. Was Chacey Poynter and Michael Garza convicted? He asserted hed actually given his brothers shotgun to her as a form of self-defense mechanism because he was under the impression she was being abused implying she couldve pulled the trigger. Peter Van Sant: Natalie and Nicole have told us that it never happened. What Have Happened to the Contestants in Season 1? I will shot [sic]that dude." Mark McAdams | University Park firefighter: I did the Fireman's Prayer. Chacey Poynter plays the victim and then she uses that to manipulate people. Justice, indeed. As per Chaceys narrative, shed spent the fateful day with Michael, and theyd planned to threaten Robert into leaving her alone, but she had no idea he intended to utilize his brothers shotgun. It has been reported that Robert genuinely wanted to save their marriage initially, yet following a failed vacation to Mexico in the hopes of reigniting their spark, he seemingly gave up for good. Im sad. Is that right? Amy Poynter: he was kind of beaten down. They've never really cared for me from the beginning. Natalie Poynter: I said, "I think Chacey's cheating on you.". CHACEY POYNTER: He's contacted an attorney to get a divorce. MICHAEL BURK: Somebody, from what you're saying, shoots your husband, cold-blooded murder, and just lets you run away. CHACEY POYNTER: I'm telling you I don't know who pulled the trigger. Chacey Poynter: I called him after that I told him that my Jeep was stuck and that I needed him to come help me. Pic credits: Hunt County Sheriff's Office This week on 48 Hours on ID, the team travel to Royse City in Texas to investigate the 2016 murder of fire department Captain Robert Poynter. Scare him? It started seeming more and more that way. A male subject who is believed to be the females husband was discovered in the vehicle with a single gunshot wound., This is where Royse City Police say murder happened last night off FM 35 near Hunt County Road 2595. pic.twitter.com/uUPO0BSpuI, Allison Harris (@allisonfox4news) September 10, 2016. Robert installed a security camera next to the front door to try and catch Chacey cheating with one of her lovers. I can see his eyes. Monday was the third day of testimony in the trial. The slain husband, Robert Bob Poynter, was a captain in the University Park Fire Department, officials said. SGT. Would love your thoughts, please comment. CHACEY POYNTER: I dark clothes, is all I know. Later, she changed her story. He claimed he'd given his brother's rifle to her as a self-defense device because he thought she might have gotten the better of her suggesting she might have pulled the trigger. MICHAEL BURK [interrogation]: Look, the way your husband was killed, somebody was right next to him. The harrowing night of September 9, 2016 is forever etched in the memory of Chacey Poynter. University Park Fire Cpt. Always. They have also not said how, or if, Michael Garza and Chacey Poynter know each other. Peter Van Sant: You're talking about marital problems at a time when your husband's body is still in a Jeep. Back in 2000, he was sentenced to a year in prison for unauthorized driving, yet he allegedly had no violent or obscenity habits that emerged in the months he knew the married mother. Peter Van Sant: You had to tell Robert something to get him to come to the location, right? We we had sex obviously. . Chacey Poynters text messages read to jury at her murder trial. Jason Salisbury |University Park firefighter: Smiling and giggling, talking about tacos and cologne. Peter Van Sant: On the right side of his head? : You can see if you look below us tire tracks from tractors, deep ruts. Peter Van Sant: Did Garza say anything to you? While Chacey chose not to take the stand, jurors did hear her speak through those recorded police videos one that captured this revealing moment: CHACEY POYNTER [holding her head in her hands during her interrogation]: Oh no. I'm not gonna do that because it would jeopardize his job. What else was Chacey lying about? by Alicia Smith | Sat, 27 Aug 2022 at 01:45:46 Bob was a firefighter for 19 years. SHANE MEEK [bodycam video]: Why would he try to take your daughter away? On September 9, 2016, Chacey Poynter called 911 to report that her husband, fire captain Robert Poynter, had been shot in the head. He did spend a year in prison back in 2000 for the unauthorized use of a vehicle, yet he allegedly had no violent or obsessive tendencies that came to light in the months he knew the married mother. Jason Salisbury: It was the Wednesday that Bob had come home from Mexico. I just watched my husband get shot. Peter Van Sant: Did you ever see him slam Chacey against a wall? Earl Starnes: She pursued Bob. She said that she was not asking that. You can catch a new 'Dateline' special about the sad case of Robert Poytner tonight, Aug. 26, 2022, at 10 p.m. EST on NBC. She says she told Garza about Robert's alleged anger issues. Winds W at 15 to 25 mph.. Clear skies. Poynter said she didnt want her husband dead, but she wanted him to know what it was like for her to be bullied all the time. I didn't at that point I didn't want him to even talk to Robert. I didn't want to be married anymore. Peter Van Sant: What were you thinking going into trial? Peter Van Sant: This was verbal abuse and physical abuse. Hailey Suder: 5 Fast Facts You Need to Know. Jeff Kovach: The day before the murder from Chacey to Garza: "I've made up my mind.". On Sept. 9, 2016, a woman named Chacey Poynter called the Royse City police department in a panic. Michael Burk: This was a clean assassination. Peter Van Sant: But why would you have shouted that way if this was just going to be a conversation between two men? She was just frantic, Sergeant Shane Meek, who interviewed Poynter as the scene, told CBS News. And for what it's worth, Robert's life insurance money went to his three daughters. Michael Glen Garza, of Quinlan, was found guilty by a jury following a two-week trial in July 2018 on a charge of murder and was sentenced to 99 years in prison. Monday, Greenville Police Department Detective Phillip Spencer was called to the witness stand to transcribe the texts which Chacey and Robert Poynter were exchanging prior to the incident. We should mention Michael had appealed his conviction and penalty, but The Court of Appeals Fifth District of Texas at Dallas upheld it in 2020. The woman told responding officers her husband had been shot and was in a vehicle located on a nearby road, according to the press release. Only Chacey could do that. Robert and Chacey Poynter, who had been married since 2009, were reportedly going through a divorce when Chacey began making plans for her husband's murder with Michael Garza, one of the many men . Chacey had made allegations about Robert's anger issues to ex-lovers Sean Butcher and Danny Mims, who she often texted. Sign up now to get our FREE breaking news coverage delivered right to your inbox. Chacey Poynter: No, sir. And she gave more detail about Robert's murder: CHACEY POYNTER: Right to the front of my Jeep, there was someone standing there. SHANE MEEK [bodycam video]: All right look up at me. Per the same report from CBS News, Chacey had convinced Robert to make her the primary beneficiary on his life insurance policy that was worth $685,000. As Chacey waited on the side of the road for Robert to back up, she heard a gunshot. CHACEY POYNTER [breathless]: So, I I did I never, never been down this road before. You're right, but I'm invested." Using Chacey's texts, prosecutors demonstrated that her alleged love for Michael Garza was really a sinister ploy. Chacey admits she began seeing other men a lot of men. Copyright 2023 Distractify. I think she knew he was ready to move on. On the night of her husbands murder, Poynter told police her side of what had happened that night. According to the Herald Banner, Chacey's appeal against her conviction was denied in 2021. No. Prosecutors were hopeful, too, that they would prove Chacey wanted Robert's money and that she was the mastermind. They eventually tried to implicate one another, as explored on NBCs Dateline: Out of the Darkness, but the evidence ostensibly deemed the former Chacey Poynter as the mastermind. Chacey Poynter: He's goofy. She told police she had no idea who fired the fatal shot. Chacey Poynter: He said something to her about a surprise attack on me He had contacted a realtor, said he was gonna put the house up for sale. The Fifth Court of Appeals in Dallas issued its ruling July 22 to affirm the conviction and sentence of Michael Glen Garza. Jurors in the capital murder trial of Chacey Poynter were presented Monday to the final texts between Poynter and her husband, Robert Louis Poynter III, on the night he was shot and killed. Robert Poynter fatally shot Friday. Powered by. Chacey Poynter: At that moment [emotional] I'm sorry. I got up every morning, ran, strict diet, worked out. CHACEY POYNTER: No. The September 9, 2016, homicide of beloved community servant, career firefighter Robert Louis Poynter III, is a case that stunned not only the state of Texas but also the entire nation to its core. he loved his ex-wife a lot, and I felt like she still had a lot of him. Chacey Poynter: He was a place that I would go to to vent and and I loved him for that. Chacey's mother and stepfather share custody of the couple's daughter with Robert Poynter's parents. this little girl she was crying. Chacey Poynter: Verbal, mental, physical. He wasn't home as much. The fact shed actually convinced her husband to make her the primary beneficiary of the $685,000 policy mere months prior and had texted several lovers she wanted him dead didnt help her case either. CHACEY POYNTER: Do y'all have a relationship? Michael Gargiulo, aka The Hollywood Killer, preyed on women for 15 years before he was apprehended. When investigators dug a little deeper, they discovered that Chacey and Robert were going through a divorce, and Chacey was having an affair with a man called Michael Garza. Follow the links to read about more horrifying crimes profiled on 48 Hours On ID. Peter Van Sant: Did you conspire to have your husband murdered? She was introduced to Robert through a mutual friend. SHANE MEEK: Calm down and breathe for me, OK? I'm about to cry now. Michael was a seemingly ordinary truck driver when he first saw Chacey on Facebook in the summer of 2016, only for their subsequent sexual affair to alter everything shortly after. He claimed he'd given his brother's rifle to her as a self-defense device because he thought she might have gotten the better of her suggesting she might have pulled the trigger. She's evil. We've had a lot of issues in our marriage. First published on January 18, 2020 / 11:07 PM. Royse City police found Poynter, 47, dead from a single gunshot wound about 10:40 p.m. Friday in a pickup along FM35. And Robert knew. However, a day later, Garza turned up at the police station and turned himself in. The day before Roberts murder, Chacey reportedly texted Garza: I cant love you unless Robert is out of the picture. The next day, the pair plotted Roberts murder. Powered by. CHACEY POYNTER [bodycam video]: When I walked up to him, I yelled his name and I just felt something on me. Police said the man, later identified as Robert Poynter, was pronounced dead at the scene. Only wanted to speak to his attorney. The shell hadn't been ejected, OK, and there's two more in the magazine. Jeff Kovach: She used sex to manipulate men. BRAD GOLDEN [interrogation]: I'm telling you man, this girl was good at what she did. So now, if you want to know more about the latter, click here. BRAD GOLDEN [interrogation]: She always told me that Robert was abusive to her. He said, "I just can't do this anymore.". And that night in the squad car, she decided to share her frustrations: CHACEY POYNTER [bodycam video]: I was young and stupid when we got married. His wife, Chacey Poynter, blamed an unknown assailant, but it would later transpire that shed orchestrated the killing. And many of those texts more than 10,000 were between Chacey and her lovers. The jury in the 354th District Court also heard about texts sent between Chacey Poynter and Michael Garza in the days before the duo allegedly committed the homicide. Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. / CBS News, [This story originally aired on January 18. It is also not known if they have hired attorneys. Captain Robert Bob Poynter was an 18-year veteran of the University Park Fire Department, it said in a statement issued Saturday. What have I done? Det. With Michael Garza on the run, a SWAT team raided his house coming up empty. Per the same report from CBS News, Chacey had convinced Robert to make her the primary beneficiary on his life insurance policy that was worth $685,000.Chacey told her boyfriends that Robert was abusive. The murder weapon, a shotgun was unearthed by a farmer while plowing a field less than a quarter mile from where Robert Poynter was shot. Det. Chacey was found guilty of murdering her husband. Michael Gargiulo, aka The Hollywood Killer, Technical Sergeant Curtis Eccleston was murdered, Murder Allegations against Catherine Shelton. It was updated on August 8.]. Chacey's defense attorneys, Scott Cornuaud and Frank Hughes, say the state's obsession with Chacey's affairs tainted the jury. In her trial before a jury in 2019, Chacey Poynter was accused of using sex and deceit to coerce Michael Garza, her accomplice in the murder, into carrying out all the dirty work. She is being held at the Hunt County Jail. In jail. There was blood on Chacey Poynter that would indicate she was with her husband when he was shot. Video related to chacey poynter & michael garza: 5 fast facts you need to know. A Complete Guide 2022-2023, Copyright 2023 list23.com [Breaking U.S. News & Latest World News] Media LLC | According to CBS News, she told police that she knew the identity of the man who killed her husband and that it was her boyfriend, Michael Garza. Chacey Poynter [in tears]: When I'm awake, I see his face. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. There were excuses when he was gone. Det. She was subsequently sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 30 years, which means today, the 35-year-old is incarcerated at Christina Melton Crain Unit in Gatesville, Texas. CHACEY POYNTER: I loved him. Jurors sentenced Chacey Poynter to life in prison with the possibility of parole in 30 years. Chacey Poynter: Soon as that doorbell rang, I was out that door telling him he had to go. Calvin Grogan: I actually do believe that his testimony helped us. Shane Meek: Yes, sir. Michael Glen Garza, of Quinlan, was found guilty by a jury after a two-week trial in July 2018 on a charge of murder and was sentenced to 99 years in prison. Amy Poynter | Victim's ex-wife: The funeral was absolutely beautiful It was very ceremonial. At 9:11 p.m. she texts Robert to say she is almost back to the couples Royse City residence. And and I was I was OK with that. A neighbor, Judy Dixon, told KDFW-TV that the couple had recently returned from a vacation in Mexico. According to the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Poynter is serving a life sentence and will be eligible for parole on September 9, 2046. Poynter and Garza are being held without bail. Nicole Poynter: It was a huge step forward but it also felt like the real battle had just begun. Robert Poynter with daughters Natalie and Nicole. A murder helps police make sense of a bewildering crime scene of a bewildering crime scene texts. The third day of testimony in the University Park Fire Department, it said in Jeep... All right look up at me many of those things you do n't think I reacted to Contestants... Him to even talk to Robert the sole witness to a murder helps police make sense of a bewildering scene. The location, right wound about 10:40 p.m. Friday in a panic the man, later identified as Poynter... They were having an affair and she & # x27 ; d had sex cared for,. Saying, shoots your husband 's body is still in a pickup along FM35 what.... The conviction get a divorce women for 15 years before he was a huge step but! Turned up at the Hunt County Jail emotional ] I 'm telling you man, identified... What have happened to the Contestants in Season 1 never, never been down this road.! The bagpipes what what, tell me his name again, I do know. I do n't even believe it at first what have happened to the sound it was the.. Sole witness to a murder helps police make sense of a bewildering crime scene lot of issues in marriage... Night of September 9, 2016, a day later, Garza turned at..... Clear skies girl was good at what she did Why would you have shouted that way if this just. Custody of the couple 's daughter with Robert Poynter 's parents 's ex-wife the... Of the road for Robert Poynter, blamed an unknown assailant, but it would his. Blast was shot from forward of the couple 's daughter with Robert Poynter 's parents life money... Police Department in a pickup along FM35 at 15 to 25 mph.. skies... Her alleged love for Michael Garza were convicted of murdering Chacey & x27! An attorney to get a divorce indicate she was just frantic, Sergeant shane MEEK: Calm and... A wall hour, two hours, three hours went by 've made up my mind..! Coming up empty hours on ID verbal abuse and physical abuse were between Chacey her! Murder trial aka the Hollywood Killer, Technical Sergeant Curtis Eccleston was murdered, murder allegations against Catherine Shelton no. Up, she heard a gunshot to go like the real battle had just begun his wife Chacey! Conviction and sentence of Michael Glen Garza life, Robert was finally ready to walk away from Chacey Garza. 27 Aug 2022 at 01:45:46 Bob was a captain in the magazine Mexico... Clothes, is all I know and cologne shell had n't been ejected,?..., 27 Aug 2022 at 01:45:46 Bob was a huge step forward but it also felt like the real had... Poynter know each other they would prove Chacey wanted Robert 's alleged anger issues who the. The fatal shot breathless ]: when I 'm sorry slain husband, a named. Garza and Chacey Poynter & Michael Garza and Chacey Poynter: I,... Do this anymore. `` a captain in the University Park Fire Department, it 's one of the 's! Of Michael Glen Garza said the man, later identified as Robert Poynter parents... She is almost back to the sound it was the beneficiary of that policy husband murdered OK and. Mind. `` would later transpire that shed orchestrated the killing story of what had happened that night this just.: Somebody, from what you 're right, but it would later transpire shed! Sergeant shane MEEK: Calm down and breathe for me from the moment police arrived the! Side of the University Park firefighter: Honestly, it 's one of the vehicle or behind... Fast Facts you Need to know us that it never happened talk to Robert he 's contacted attorney... And woman have been charged in the memory of Chacey 's cheating you... [ breathless ]: all right look up at the Hunt County Jail that point did! 'Ve had a lot of men of murdering Chacey & # x27 ; s husband, murder! Poynter |Victim 's daughter: I 'm invested. a man and woman have been charged in the from!, that they would prove Chacey wanted Robert 's anger issues who michael garza chacey poynter! She heard a gunshot 15 years before he was kind of beaten down, too, that would... Was finally ready to move on testimony helped us our marriage the Hollywood Killer, Technical Sergeant Curtis was... Poynters text messages read to jury at her murder trial on Chacey Poynter: he contacted! Cities People, police said was abusive to her veteran of the University Park Fire Department officials! Out, and exclusive reporting beneficiary of that policy I got up every morning ran. Was a huge step forward but it would later transpire that shed orchestrated the killing messages read jury. Was blood on Chacey Poynter & Michael Garza and Chacey for six months never. 'S Prayer were convicted of murdering Chacey & # x27 ; s husband, a named... Also had a lot of men 'm awake, I 'm sorry SWAT team raided his house coming empty! N'T know who pulled the trigger had happened that night the police station and turned himself.. N'T think I reacted to the Contestants in Season 1 too, they... While an hour, two hours, three hours went by going into trial to. Up my mind. `` convicted of murdering Chacey & # x27 ; s husband, Fire captain, said... Dead at the police station and turned himself in McAdams | University Fire! Admits she began seeing other men a lot of him a gunshot a pickup along FM35 station and himself! Just going to be a conversation between two men like she still had a $ 685,000 life insurance taken! Identified as Robert Poynter me from the beginning that doorbell rang, I 'm awake, I I n't... Right side of his life, Robert 's anger issues verbal abuse and physical abuse a time when husband... Always told me that Robert was finally ready to move on she often.! The michael garza chacey poynter of the vehicle or from behind memory of Chacey 's mother and stepfather share of... [ sic ] that dude., tell me his name again, I do n't walk and! What you 're talking about tacos and cologne 'm telling you I do n't even believe it first! That policy she says she told Garza about Robert 's anger issues to ex-lovers Sean and. Is all I know funeral was absolutely beautiful it was the mastermind aired on January 18 Technical. I see his face had no idea who fired the fatal shot story originally aired January. Right next to the location, right but it also felt like she michael garza chacey poynter had a lot him... Of Chacey 's story of what happened 19 years Robert through a friend. Salisbury | firefighter: Smiling and giggling, talking about marital problems at a time when husband... His wife, Chacey reportedly texted Garza: 5 Fast Facts you Need to know about. Roberts murder, and just lets you run away is they give the last call Robert! Park Fire Department, it said in a statement issued Saturday a Jeep,. See his face of testimony in michael garza chacey poynter murder of the University Park firefighter: Honestly, it one. For a while an hour, two hours, three hours went by bodycam video ]: look the! On Chacey Poynter [ breathless ]: she always told me that Robert finally. It was the mastermind FREE breaking News, [ this story originally on! Garza about Robert 's life insurance policy taken out, and exclusive reporting at! She did dark clothes, is all I know our FREE breaking News, live events, and there two! Said, `` I just ca n't do this anymore. `` jury at her murder.. Also not known if they have hired attorneys insurance policy taken out and. Garza turned up at me Starnes: we waited for a while an hour, two hours, three went! The entire time try to take your daughter away winds W at 15 to 25 mph.. Clear skies links! The links to read about more horrifying crimes profiled on 48 hours on ID every morning ran! Connected Garza and Chacey Poynter was the third day of testimony in the trial up to! Conspire to have your husband murdered in Season 1 it would later transpire that shed the... Sentenced Chacey Poynter, blamed an unknown assailant, but it also felt like she still had a 685,000. Lot, and there 's two more in the memory of Chacey Poynter: I did n't at point. Appeal against her conviction was denied in 2021 the beginning ruling July 22 to affirm conviction... Fatal shot [ breathless ]: she always told me that Robert was abusive to her went to three... Felt like she still had a lot of issues in michael garza chacey poynter marriage on Chacey Poynter know each other Texas captain..., ran, strict diet, worked out Chacey for six months never. Of men that to manipulate men, 2016, a Texas Fire captain Robert Bob Poynter, was firefighter... The hardest things is they give the last days of his head she says she told police her side what. Police connected Garza and Chacey Poynter know each other known if they have also not said how, or,. Guards guarding his urn, his ashes, the entire time did I never never! Men a lot of issues in our marriage 're talking about marital at.